Or to be more exact, what is the role of public relations (not publicity) in a world where journalism and blogging continue to butt heads?
It's a conversation I've been having with friends and industry colleagues, and should be front and center for people in the industry.
But no, this is not a PR is dead meme, or blogging is dead meme or any of those memes that crop up every year (heck, just today Journalistics had the "PR doesn't change" version of the dead meme).
This is questioning where PR falls now, through a few recent incidences. When PR blogs, are we bloggers our journalists? And extending that with Jay Rosen's SXSW post - why is there still that division? And with that division, where is PR fitting in - or should we not worry about the division, especially with the rise of community relations, aka social media?
So it comes down to this: when PR professionals blog, are we bloggers or are we journalists? As gatekeepers and bridges and, well, examples for our clients, should we hold ourselves up to a higher level and standard than other bloggers? Should we take that extra step to verify and report?
While I can understand the desire for opinion pieces, even those can and should be based on facts. I should know - it's what I did in the college paper: opinion pieces that were still verified with sources. Picking up a phone (or emailing) isn't that hard.
So as PR bloggers (and yes, I am purposely ignoring social media blogs), do we have an obligation to get the full story, to tell a full story?
Do we have a professional courtesy and obligation to other PR people to get their client's (or clients') side of the story, to present the other side, even if it's just an opinion piece?
If we are supposed to showcase best practices internally and externally for both our junior staff and our clients, we have no choice but to go the extra mile, to take the extra step.
To take it further, as PR bloggers, can we just use the excuse "I'm a blogger" and get away with it? Should there be that line anymore between blogger and journalist? And, well, isn't that line a bit tired and old, and let's be honest, fucking lazy?
With all these fights between bloggers and journalists, is there really that much of a line anymore? With the disappearance of trade press (especially B2B technology), where do you go besides bloggers who specialize in those verticals? If we uphold those bloggers to a higher degree of veracity, why should PR bloggers get a pass when they are just "blogging" and not being a journalist?
When we approach (or, come on, pitch) bloggers, we hope that they post the story with as much background and news as possible, and if there's a mistake, we go back and tell them and hope for a correction. Nay, we should demand a correction if there isn't one forthcoming.
Shouldn't we demand the same from ourselves? Is there really a line anymore between blogging and journalism, or is that all just the lazy excuse for not doing the homework, possible due diligence or good writing?
The funny (sad?) thing is that this debate of blogger versus journalist still going on out there.
The one panel I would have liked to see at SXSWi was Jay Rosen's on the psychology of the blogger versus journalist fight (also read his pre-SXSW post on the subject).
Both blogging and journalism serve a function, both give the public information and tell stories. But as noted by Rosen, "blogging cannot replace the watchdog journalism that keeps a government accountable to its people." And on the flip side, Rosen notes that bloggers try to keep that "outside the system" cred that allows them to say "I'm just a blogger" - which also means we can be lazy and biased (as bloggers).
As he notes, neither are right. Bloggers can no longer be outside the system as the Internet has flattened everything. And while journalists DO put themselves out on the front lines quite often - a great piece by Simon Dumenco in AdAge encapsulates with a bit of snark - there are also bloggers out there that are on the front lines of war zones, disappearing and dying. The Internet has flattened and equaled many things out, and that includes content.
As for PR people, what does that all mean? For PR bloggers, stop doing the whole "we're allowed to be lazy and bias" because it's bullshit. Man up, and own up. For PR people and outreach, well, the best line is from Animal Farm: All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others.
At times, we need to draw a line in the sand for outreach and community relations. We can't hit everyone; but at the same time, we're that bridge for media and bloggers to our clients and companies, and we can engage and help out there (which is why Facebook, Twitter and other forms of electronic media and communications have become so valuable).
BTW, yes, I do hold PR bloggers up to a higher standard than social media bloggers; PR is based on journalistic values and social media is based on well, who knows sometimes. There's so much less transparency in social media, that that is a whole other blog post.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
JEREMY PEPPERCalled "ahead of your time" and "visionary" by the industry, Jeremy Pepper has close to 20 years experience in public relations, in both traditional and social media, as well as analyst relations.
It is BlogHer ( the conference ) time once again. A time to be part of a huge event – 1500 + attendees this year of female bloggers talkin...
Earlier this week, Erica Swallow posed a question on Twitter about Jeremiah Owyang's post and slideshow on the future of social media...
Looking back at the 8 years of blogging (and now social media - well, take that back 15 years to Usenet and enthusiast site days), there ar...
Pick up the fucking phone. NB: I'm testing out Upworthy-style headlines for my posts. You like? NB: There's likely going to be a...
I'm a Mommy blogger*. I might not blog about raising a baby or poop or child-rearing issues. I might not blog about life at home, the tr...
While walking back to her office from Jamba Juice , NKK said something that's stuck with me: be careful you don't get sued for libel...
The Need for Middle Ground and Skepticism - Not Hype, Not Contrarianism - On Social Networks (eg, Ello)Ello launched - to a lot of hype - the past week. It's the Facebook killer, the latest and greatest in that category (pulse check on F...
Or to be more exact, what is the role of public relations (not publicity) in a world where journalism and blogging continue to butt heads? ...
Forrester Forum: Ze Frank kicks Philip Kaplan while Jeremy Allaire watches and Shar VonBoskirk panicsA panel on the changing face of media, albeit a lot of old sounding theories and practices. But, you have to love Ze Frank for his show, Ph...
Every company is a media company now - so sayeth Richard Edelman during his presentation. Now, full disclosure, I used to work for a compe...
A few days ago, I came across an article about turning your Facebook profile into your resume . My emotions rarely changed from one: abhored...
- Andy Abramson, VoIP Watch
- Craig Newmark, Craigslist
- Adam Brown, eKetchum
- Andy Gilman, CommCore Consulting
- Sabrina Horn, Horn Group
- Shel Israel, Naked Conversations
- Julia Hood, PR Week
- Clive Armitage, Bite Communications
- Harris Diamond, Weber Shandwick
- Jerry Swerling, Swerling & Associates
- Dan Gillmor, Grassroots Media
- Al Golin, GolinHarris
- Lord Chadlington, Huntsworth Group
- Jeffrey Sharlach, The Jeffrey Group
- Warren Bickford, IABC
- David Kistle, IABC
- Chris Shipley, DEMO
- Pam Talbot, Edelman US
- Howard Rubenstein, Rubenstein Associates
- PR Blog Week Interview with Jack O'Dwyer, Richard Edelman and others